Anonymous
sent a message
One of my main issues with captain Carter is that she basically has steves back story but she isn't him not i don't mean this in a fan boy type hater way but it feels like an empty title with her . While characters like Sam and Steve the current caps actually feel like the mean something and their impact is shown.
I just feel like she should have stayed in the past and Steve should have been allowed to move on in a better way
valkyrieandstrangeridingaragorn:
It feels empty because while we see Steve care about other people we don’t see that with her. She’s completely self-centered which wouldn’t be a problem if she was framed accurately instead of the ‘female Steve’ because she’s nothing like him.
Ep1 of What If is my least favourite episode and clearly the one they didn’t put any effort in. It basically gives Steve’s quotes to her, they replaced Bucky and every scene he has with Steve so they could shoehorn her into the story and it’s all about her physical strength when Erskine in TFA had made it abundantly clear that he chose Steve because he was a good man, not a good soldier.
The difference between her and Sam is that we do see him basically act like Steve in many occasions: in TWS when he’s willing to get back to the fight in order to stop Pierce and Hydra, when he joins Steve to help him find Bucky even though he’s not sure Buck is salvageable, when he’s the first to speak up against the Accords or when he gives orders to Steve in the airport. Sam’s worthiness of the shield and mantle is not about his physical strength, it’s about him being a good man who’s willing to defend and protect everyone else.
What we see in Peggy is that she thinks she’s superior to everyone else and in order to prove that she kicks ass and gets involved in the fight… but do we ever hear from her what her political stance is? We don’t.
All this not mentioning Marvel’s obsession with shoehorning her character over and over again even at the expense of Sam. At this point I’m starting to wonder if they’re going to include her in the 4th Cap movie as well, replacing Bucky perhaps. It wouldn’t surprise me in the slightest…